New Garner is a little further away from the dances-good swimming holes-a little smaller sites.Old Garner is closer to dances-good swimming-larger spots,but any spot at Garner is fine with my family.Also are you going to tent or rv?Dw and Dd like new for rv and old for tents, Ds and Me don't care just so we can swim,hike, and bike.
srds
Have Fun