Originally Posted by Alchemist2000

I guess the relative lengths of the two trails depends at least somewhat on the campsite we are aiming for. Are there campsites along the South Rim that are much preferable than others and/or campsites that should defiinitely be avoided? I have looked at the descriptions on the BB website, but I would love to hear from those of you that have actually been there. Right now we are thinking about two nights. One day up, one day to dayhike in the rim area (probably without moving the campsite, although that would also be an option), and then come back on the third day. Due to the weight of the water, I think we could only think about three nights if we could get water from Boot Springs.