lost_but_found

There is a bunch of good information here.

I wear a Gore-Tex low top adventure shoe. I have strong ankles so I like the freedom. But the Gore-Tex helps keep the morning moisture from grass out of your shoe and does allow you to manage low water with dry feet. I am with toejam that a well built leather boot is going to keep your feet dry with or without Gore-Tex.

I am a firm believer in finding what works for you. REI will let you wear their boots all around the store. Wear a pair of your hiking socks to get the proper fit as well.

If there is any little movement, somewhat uncomfortable spot, or bunching, it will be magnified tremendously after a full days hike with the stone on your back. So keep that in mind when choosing your next boot. Scrutinize and critique them to the max. This is one of the most important buys for your overall comfort on the trail. Ask the person at REI to measure your foot and recommend something, but always go with your intuition. If you can't find anything that feels right, don't settle for less! Keep looking.
Good luck!